This guy likes me and i don't know what to do!!?

okay, im in middle school. And theres this new kid. He likes me. I found that out on the second day of school. Anyways, on myspace there is these truth box things and he put one saying ''i want to get to know you better''. and i messaged him and started talking to him and after a few messages he asked me to go to my schools football game on friday. And i said sure. Now he told me that he likes me. And i said that i kind of like him. but now i'm not sure if i do...because i kind of lke this other guy. But me and that guy have gone out before and it didn't work. actually 2 times and i never really stopped liking him. I mean i think i should be open to new possibilities. what do you guys think?